My experience with selling my home by owner
I have had my home on the market for 90 days now, and I get a lot of questions about what it is like to sell your home by owner. So, I thought I would take some time to talk about how it has been so far. As some background information, I decided to list my house for 6 months by owner before I hired a real estate agent. The big justification for doing so is the 3% savings I could potentially see if I am successful. At $150,000, that rounds out to $4,500—not a small chunk of change.
Marketing. I am going to start out with the most important part of the process—marketing. My experience is from the St. Louis market, but I am pretty sure it would transfer to where you are at. To date, I have considered several forms of marketing: (1) craigslist, (2) word of mouth, (3) newspaper, (4) flat-fee MLS, and (5) signage. Out of those, I have implemented 1, 2, 4, and 5. I decided not to put my property up in the newspaper because my local paper, the St. Louis Post Dispatch, is priced ridiculous. Their packages start at $300 for web and paper coverage. And, honestly, when I looked around the listing, I saw very few FSBO homes. I wonder why. Out of the the four marketing avenues I have worked, to date I have only received responses from items 4 and 5—the flat-fee MLS and signage. Both of these have been extremely effective. This week alone I have gotten 1 walk through from signage, 1 walk through from the flat-fee MLS, and 1 call from the flat-fee MLS. Surprisingly, I have received zero serious inquiries from craigslist. I say “serious” because I do get emailed spammed left-and-right from local real estate agents every time I post there. I attribute this to two reasons: (1) most people buying a house have a buyer’s agent and they use the MLS and (2) craigslist is overwhelmed with listings in the real estate section.
By the way, if you are interested in going the flat-fee route, I recommend soldbyme.com in the St. Louis area. They have been great.
Showings. Showing by far are the worst part of selling a home. Before I started doing showings, I thought the 3% commission was outrageous. Now, I am coming around a bit because when you are selling your home, you personally have to do all the work. In terms of actually doing the showings, my lessons learned are pretty simple: (1) keep your house clean, (2) protect yourself, (3) be honest about the situation, and (4) stay out of the other realtor’s way. One is pretty self explanatory, so I will skip it.
To protect myself, I do three things. The first is that I reverse phone lookup anyone that calls me. 90% of the time it will trace back to a real estate office, so you know that the call is valid. The second thing I do is I look up the person on Google. It is a good validation check, and often you get match a name with a face. The third thing that I do is when I am showing the house, I get a card and often get the license plate of the realtor. This is easy if you follow step #4. This all might be overkill, but I don’t think you can be too careful when dealing with strangers.
The next two lessons-learned are related and can be really grouped into one tenant: respect the other realtor. When I get a call, I am always upfront and explain that my house is for sale by owner, I listed it on the MLS using a flat-fee broker, and that I will (and am obligated) to pay their commission. Believe it or not, most realtors do not run into this situation on a daily basis. In fact, I have gotten a number of questions about how I listed my house on the MLS. So, this upfront honesty is important. The next piece of advice is from HGTV, but I think it holds true: stay out of the other realtor’s way. I let the other realtor show the house. In fact, I go outside for every showing. It is 10 degrees outside right now, so believe me, it is tough. But, the worst thing you can do when you show a house is to walk around with the other realtor. Of course, it goes without saying, to not keep anything small of value laying around your house. I figure I should be able to notice if someone walks out with my HDTV.
Frustrations. I think the biggest frustration I have had when showing the house, is that lack of notice you often get. I often get a call in the morning for an afternoon showing. I am not sure if this is the industry standard, but I think that this would be pretty tough for families even if you went the traditional route of selling your home. The second big frustration is the lack of background research other realtors do before showing a house. I have a two story town home, and I have gotten a couple walk throughs where the biggest complaint was that people did not like steps. I think the realtor probably should have eliminated this earlier in the process. These incidents are pretty isolated, but when it happens, it is a bit annoying.
Conclusion. Overall, I am really trying to be positive about the process. Of course, if I sell the property, it will be worth the time and effort. But, if I come out empty handed, I am not sure I will feel the same way. In the end, the process provided a good life lesson and really gave me a lot of insight into the process of buying and selling a home.









January 8th, 2010 at 10:15 am
I thought you were crazy when you told me you were selling it yourself. Based on the 1 house I bought, I remember just hitting an area and seeing signs or even door keys in the area (after my scheduled visits) so my agent would call the other agent to setup an appointment immediately. That is how I found my place. We visited one unit in my building and saw three other units that we did not know about. Plus, I did most of my viewings during the week (not sure if I even looked at a place on the weekend) and we were looking at houses that people lived in but were at work so basically going through their lived-in house (some clean and some not). You could get lucky and sell your house and save that 3% but your chances are greater in a good market which is not the case. Personally, I don’t think the 3% in worth the time and trouble so I think I would go through an agent. Good post though as I liked seeing your thought pattern and experience so far.
January 8th, 2010 at 12:29 pm
@Eric Agreed. In a good market, I think I would have just hired a real estate agent and foregone all the trouble. But that 3% is tough to swallow when it is coming out of the equity in your house.
January 11th, 2010 at 6:52 am
If you list it in newspaper, add a blurb about open house! Every Sunday 2-4. Be ready we balloons, water and a smile. Also, you ever think about getting your realtor license? 400 bucks and an hour of studying could save you thousands!
January 11th, 2010 at 7:01 am
@Jacob I did take a real estate class as part of my MBA. The instructor said that (at least in MO), you do not need a license to represent yourself in a real estate transaction. And, that unless you plan to pursue it as a career, you probably don’t need a license. But, I could definitely be missing something.
January 12th, 2010 at 9:42 am
I’m wondering how much of a loss you are willing to take on this condo. Does getting a realtor virtually guarantee you’ll be walking away losing money? Or are you going to think about renting it out for awhile and let the economy recover?
January 12th, 2010 at 10:08 am
@Nick At my current list price, I would take a loss one way or the other (without considering tax benefits). If I have a realtor, that loss would be increased by 3%…between $4000 and $5000.
March 1st, 2010 at 10:37 am
[...] is a follow-up post to one I wrote a month ago about selling my home by owner. The outcome of the prior is now pretty obvious: I was completely unsuccessful at selling my [...]
March 1st, 2010 at 4:07 pm
Hi Matt, just read both your posts. I too was interested in your process. As a REALTOR® I am biased of course, but after a decade in the business I can tell you that hiring an experienced agent to get your home sold will net you more than selling on your own. Time and again I see 1st hand, FSBO’s selling well below their asking price, and really below market. A good REALTOR® works hard to attract serious buyers and with experience facilitating contracts negotiates far better than most owners. I sure hope your renting experience goes well for you. All the best.